Investments Tenets- Sarsi’s Approach

SHARE THIS POST

 1.     A focus on downside protection helps performance over the long term

Research has shown that for most investors the pain of a loss is more acute than the pleasure of an equal gain. There is more to downside protection from an investment strategy point of view: negative returns have a bigger impact on long term performance than positive returns. For example:

-50% followed by +50% ≠ 0%. It is = -25%. (This is also true for +50% followed by -50%)

To drive home the impact of negative returns on long term performance, below is a table illustrating how much and how long it takes to get to breakeven after a negative performance.

Table 1

Drawdown Return needed to recoup losses No. of years to recoup losses at 10% per year
-10% 11.11% 1.11
-20% 25.00% 2.34
-30% 42.85% 3.74
-40% 66.67% 5.36
-50% 100.00% 7.28
-60% 150.00% 9.62
-70% 233.33% 12.64
-80% 400.00% 16.89
-90% 900.00% 24.16

 Source: Sarsi, LLC analysis

It is impossible to avoid negative returns all the time, but by constructing a portfolio that, over the long term captures less of the downside and more of the upside an advisor can add considerable value. To illustrate, even if the adviser reduces the downside as much as he does the upside, he would have added value. Continuing with the above example:

-50% followed by +50% = -25%.

If an adviser reduces both upside and downside by half: -25% followed by +25% = -6.25%

However, as we will see below this objective must be achieved without too much turnover and by not attempting to time the market, which is impossible to do in a consistent and reliable manner. We attempt to mitigate the effect of large protracted drawdowns and participate in large rallies.

2. Market timing is futile

Investors as a group, are terrible at timing the markets. As seen in the figure below, they chase returns, investing in stock funds after markets have reached new highs and selling after markets decline. It takes discipline and a thoughtful, reliable process to avoid falling into this trap.

Fig 1

Market Timing Futility

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

                               

   Source: Illustration by MFS Investment Management

3.     It is important to stay invested in the markets

“In risk assets you make 80% of your money 20% of the time”- A Famous Money Manager

It is imperative to be invested in the markets, as missing out a few large moves will make a huge difference to long term returns. The table below shows how an investor would have performed if she had invested in the S&P 500 over the last 5 years and how her return would have been impacted if she had missed some of the months when the S&P 500 had the best returns. Sticking to a strategic allocation based on individual risk profile enables investors to stay invested.

Table 3

S&P 500 returns last 5 years and if an investor missed the best months
5 year annualized return Value of $100,000 in five years
Invested for all periods 16.37%  $               213,387
Missed the best month returns 13.98%  $               192,373
Missed the two best months’s returns 12.15%  $               177,417
Missed the three best months’s returns 10.69%  $               166,166
Missed the four best months’s returns 9.45%  $               157,065
Missed the five best months’s returns 8.35%  $               149,329

Source: Sarsi, LLC analysis

4. A valuation based investment strategy can add value

Ideally, portfolios must be made defensive in advance of market declines. Using a metric like valuation can be an effective way of doing this. As seen in the table below, when markets are expensive, returns in the periods ahead tend to be low. However, this is not a foolproof metric and expensive markets can continue to rally. As the economist John Maynard Keynes noted, markets can remain irrational longer than investors can stay solvent. While it is impossible to get the timing exactly, investors will do well to be defensive when the valuation justifies it, even if it means being early and missing out on the last rally up before a drawdown. The converse is true when markets are cheap. Valuation based tactical allocations around a core strategic allocation enables investors to achieve this objective.

Table 3

S&P 500 returns in subsequent months/years in %: 03/1926 to 05/2014
Valuation 6 months 1 year 2 years 3 years 5 years
Above 20% -0.2 -3.6 -1.6 6.8 -0.3
Below 20% 14 19.4 30.1 47.3 65.3
Market 3.9 8 16 23.6 39.7

Source: Ned David Research, Sarsi, LLC analysis

5.     Investing for the long term increases the odds of positive performance

Most people overestimate what they can achieve in the short term and underestimate what they can achieve in the long term. The same goes for their investing performance. The need for instant gratification and the focus on short-term results leads to investors sacrificing their longer-term performance. By focusing on the long term, investors increase the odds of success and the possibility of realizing their objectives. The table below illustrates how the % of positive performance increases with time frame when looking at the returns of the S&P 500 between 1926 and 2015.

Table 4: S&P 500:1926 to 2015

S&P 500: 1926 to 2015
Time frame % of periods positive % of periods negative
Daily 54.00% 46.00%
Quarterly 68.00% 32.00%
One Year 74.00% 26.00%
5 years 86.00% 14.00%
10 years 94.00% 6.00%
15 years 100.00% 0.00%

 Source: Sarsi, LLC analysis

A related point is that to beat a benchmark, one must invest differently from a benchmark, which means there could be underperformance in the short term. Over the long term, ideally one business cycle, a good investment strategy should be able to beat the benchmark.

6.     Diversification helps mitigate drawdowns and enhances performance

Diversification has been called the ‘free lunch’ that can reduce volatility, protect portfolios from drawdowns and enhance returns. The figure below illustrates this, by considering the period between 1999 to 2015. This period was punctuated by two recessions accompanied by steep market drawdowns. A diversified portfolio of stocks and bonds would have protected investor’s wealth and performed better than an all stock portfolio.

   Fig 2

Diversification_Secondary_Chart2_640x560

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Source: Illustration by Charles Schwab

 

Thank you for signing up to receive our newsletter!

If you would you like to discuss financial planning with us, please provide your phone number.

Sarsi LLC Logo

Disclaimer

Sarsi, LLC (“Sarsi” or “the firm”) is a registered investment adviser located in New Jersey. Sarsi and its representatives are in compliance with the current registration mandates imposed on state registered investment advisers in those states where registration is required. The firm may also transact business in those states in which it maintains registration or qualifies for a corresponding exemption there from.

Use of this website is limited to the dissemination of general information regarding Sarsi’s investment advisory services offered to individuals residing in those states where providing such information is not prohibited by applicable law. Accordingly, the publication of Sarsi’s website on the internet should not be construed by any consumer as a solicitation or attempt to effect transactions in securities, or the rendering of personalized investment advice. Nothing on this website should be interpreted in any manner whatsoever as a substitute for, or the receipt of, personalized investment advice. Certain of the information contained herein may not be suitable for everyone and may be derived from external sources that are not affiliated with Sarsi. While Sarsi believes these sources to be reputable, the Firm makes no representation or guarantee as to the accuracy, timeliness or suitability, completeness or relevance of the information prepared by any unaffiliated third-party, whether linked to the website or referenced herein. All such information is provided for convenience purposes only and all users therefore should be guided accordingly. Any subsequent, direct communication with a prospective client of the Firm will be initiated by a representative whom is either registered or exempt from registration in the state in which the prospect resides.

Detailed information pertaining to Sarsi’s qualifications, business operations, fee schedule service offerings can be found in the Firm’s Disclosure Brochure which appears as Part 2A of Sarsi’s Form ADV. Additional information about Sarsi, as well as a current version of the Firm’s Disclosure Brochure, is available on the Investment Advisor Public Disclosure website which is operated by the U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission, at www.adviserinfo.sec.gov

ACCESS TO THE FIRM’S WEBSITE IS PROVIDE FOR INFORMATION PURPOSES ONLY AND WITHOUT WARRANTIES-EXPRESS OR IMPLIED-WITH REGARD TO THE ACCURACY, TIMELINESS OR RESULTS OBTAINED FROM ANY INFORMATION POSTED ON THIS WEBSITE OR ANY THIRD-PARTY WEBSITE LINKED HERETO.